 |  |
Hey Wolverines, Why So Blue?
Posted: Sep 05 2007
By Scott Hurrey
  
With the start of the 2007 NFL season looming, it takes a lot to change the water cooler conversation away from the latest power rankings or who will be the biggest surprise team in the playoffs this year. Appalachian State did just that.
If you have been living in a cave for the past week, perhaps you won't know what I'm talking about, so let me fill you in. A division AA school spent Saturday in Ann Arbor destroying the hopes and dreams of Wolverine fans around the globe. A warm-up game in early September turned out to be a burn that will be felt until next season.
The first signs of that burn can be seen in the latest polls. Last week, Michigan was sitting pretty at number 5. This week, they are unranked, marking the biggest fall in ranking since the expansion to 25 teams in 1989.
So now, as a spectator, I have to wonder what a fall like that and loss by a top-5 division I-A school to a division I-AA school means for the ranking system itself. Were the pre-season rankings that far off to begin with, or is the importance of this game to the team's ranking disproportionate?
The answer is probably both.
Losing one game basically halted Big Blue's championship aspirations in it's tracks, and I suppose being the first ranked Bowl Subdivision team to ever lose to a Championship Subdivision team will do that to you, but the real debacle here, is the pre-season poll itself. The very idea of having a pre-season ranking is ludicrous in this humble reporter's opinion. How can you set a ranking that so severely affects the National Championship hunt before a single game is played?
Sure, USC is good every year. That won't change if you make them wait a month to put it in writing. And doing so would mean the less-hyped teams would have more of an opportunity to move up the rankings. If you are projected to be bad and turn out to be good, you are automatically penalized for not being highly touted in August. The likelihood of being bumped ahead of someone ranked ahead of you with the same record is slim, even if you field a better squad.
I know the BCS system was introduced to try and correct these problems, but the problem is that a computer algorithm is dependant upon data, and two-thirds of the data used are the same subjective polls that caused the problem in the first place. I don't know what the real answer is, and maybe the BCS is a step in the right direction, but none of these options allow the players to decide on the field.
Perhaps a four-team playoff with each of the BCS winners would make things a little clearer at the end of the season; at least is would give fans three more games and the NCAA three more games worth of revenue. But that's a story for a different edition of the Cheap Seats. |
|
|
 | JansenFan
Scott Hurrey
Beat Writer |
| Number of articles written: 138 |
 |  |
|  |
Harvey, Diageo Team to Help Haiti
Jan 25 - Hog Wire
Redskins, Diageo Team to Tackle Drunk Driving
Oct 16 - Hog Wire
Happy Birthday, Sean
Apr 01 - Hog Wire
Slinging Sammy Passes at 94
Dec 18 - Hog Wire
The Fifth Quarter: Farewell Texas Stadium
Sep 29 - Hog Wire
The FIfth Quarter: New Orleans Saints
Sep 15 - Washington Redskins News
Q & A With Larry Brown
Aug 15 - Washington Redskins News
Caps Off Their Game, Off To Philly
Apr 14 - Capitals
Old Time Hockey: Caps vs. Flyers
Apr 11 - Capitals
Capital Procurement
Feb 26 - Capitals
Caps, Ovechkin In First
Feb 07 - Capitals
So Long Coach Joe
Jan 09 - Hog Wire
Gibbs Retires
Jan 08 - Hog Wire
Twenty One
Jan 03 - Hog Wire
For Caps, Accountability, Aggression Are The Keys
Dec 15 - Capitals
The Fifth Quarter: Chicago Bears
Dec 08 - Hog Wire
Forget Everything You Have Heard About Sean Taylor
Nov 28 - Hog Wire
THN On Ice: Episode 1
Oct 27 - Capitals
Lots to 'Laich' About 3-0
Oct 09 - Capitals
The Cheap Seats: Classic Buges
Sep 22 - Hog Wire
Canes Clip Caps
Sep 16 - Capitals
Hey Wolverines, Why So Blue?
Sep 05 - Other
Skins Wash Out Ravens
Aug 26 - Hog Wire
B. Lloyd Keeps His Eyes On The Prize
Aug 08 - Hog Wire
Blades, Sartz, Palmer Ink Deals
Jul 17 - Hog Wire
Caps Schedule Out
Jul 13 - Capitals
One-Timers
Jul 11 - Capitals
The B. Lloyd Show: Off-Season Update
Jul 09 - Hog Wire
A New Look Deeply Rooted In The Past
Jun 25 - Capitals
Building a Washington Team Through The Draft?
Jun 21 - Capitals
Local Students Make Difference for Olie and Autism
May 31 - Capitals
B. Lloyd Gives Time, Learns to Stay-Focused
May 22 - Hog Wire
2007 NFL Mock Draft
Apr 20 - 2007 Draft
Olie, Semin Snap Caps' Skid
Feb 05 - Capitals
Fehr Gets Call, First Career NHL Goal
Jan 29 - Capitals
Caps Thrash Atlanta in OT
Jan 08 - Capitals
The B. Lloyd Show - Episode 10
Dec 29 - Hog Wire
The B. Lloyd Show - Episode 8
Dec 13 - Hog Wire
The B. Lloyd Show - Episode 6
Nov 29 - Hog Wire
The B. Lloyd Show - Episode 4
Nov 15 - Hog Wire
B. Lloyd Talks Dallas, Music and More
Nov 08 - Hog Wire
The B. Lloyd Show - Dallas Week / Bang Out
Nov 01 - Hog Wire
THN Introduces The B. Lloyd Show
Oct 26 - Hog Wire
The Fifth Quarter - Indianapolis Colts
Oct 23 - Hog Wire
Fifth Quarter - Tennessee Titans
Oct 16 - Hog Wire
Caps Battle Thrashers, Fall Short
Oct 15 - Capitals
Fifth Quarter - New York Giants I
Oct 09 - Hog Wire
The Caps Are Back
Oct 08 - Capitals
Fifth Quarter - Houston Texans
Sep 25 - Hog Wire
Fifth Quarter - Dallas Cowboys I
Sep 17 - Game Day
Fifth Quarter: Minnesota Vikings
Sep 12 - Game Day
THN Ranked Number Three
Sep 07 - Other
The Caitlin Classic
Aug 22 - Other
THN Hogcasts Offer the Voice of the Fans
Aug 07 - 2006 Training Camp
The Dog Days Of Summer
May 16 - Hog Wire
Team Draft Needs: St. Louis Rams
Apr 27 - 2006 Draft
Team Draft Needs: Arizona Cardinals
Apr 07 - 2006 Draft
Team Draft Needs: San Francisco 49ers
Apr 06 - 2006 Draft
Team Draft Needs: New York Jets
Mar 24 - 2006 Draft
Team Draft Needs: Tennessee Titans
Mar 17 - 2006 Draft
The Salary Cap Blues
Mar 15 - Hog Wire
So Long LaVar
Mar 07 - Hog Wire
Best From the Combine
Mar 03 - 2006 Draft
Combine Results
Mar 01 - 2006 Draft
Combine Events Overview
Jan 19 - 2006 Draft
The Fifth Quarter - Seahawks
Jan 15 - The 5th Quarter
Fifth Quarter Playoff Edition - Tampa Bay
Jan 08 - The 5th Quarter
Fifth Quarter: Eagles
Jan 01 - The 5th Quarter
Fifth Quarter: Arizona Cardinals
Dec 12 - The 5th Quarter
Playoff Picture 2005: Week 14
Dec 09 - Hog Wire
Fifth Quarter: St. Louis Rams
Dec 05 - The 5th Quarter
The Fifth Quarter – Tampa Bay
Nov 14 - The 5th Quarter
The Fifth Quarter: Kansas City Chiefs
Oct 17 - The 5th Quarter
Injuries Beginning To Accumulate
Oct 13 - Hog Wire
The Fifth Quarter: Denver Broncos
Oct 09 - The 5th Quarter
THN To Host Bram Weinstein
Sep 27 - Hog Wire
The Fifth Quarter - Dallas Cowboys
Sep 19 - The 5th Quarter
Brunell Named Starter For Dallas And Beyond
Sep 13 - Hog Wire
Press Release: THN Takes Second In Tailgate Challenge
Sep 08 - Hog Wire
The Fifth Quarter – Ravens
Sep 02 - The 5th Quarter
Tough Decisions On The Horizon - Safeties
Aug 23 - Hog Wire
Ramsey's Future Depends On His Present
Aug 17 - Hog Wire
Redskins Training Camp - Day 4
Aug 04 - 2005camp
Redskins Training Camp - Day 1
Aug 01 - 2005camp
New Player Profiles: David Patten
Jul 11 - 2005camp
Best Quotes From Redskins Mini-Camp
Jun 28 - 2005 Mini Camp
Mini-Camp: THN Catches Up With Joe Tuipala
Jun 20 - 2005 Mini Camp
Mini-Camp: Antonio Brown Is Red Hot
Jun 19 - 2005 Mini Camp
Mini-Camp: Who's Ethan Albright?
Jun 19 - 2005 Mini Camp
Mini-Camp Recap: Day Two
Jun 18 - 2005 Mini Camp
Mini Camp: Ramsey's Getting Comfy
Jun 17 - 2005 Mini Camp
Mini Camp: Offensive Line Set To Shine
Jun 17 - 2005 Mini Camp
Mini-Camp Preview
Jun 16 - 2005 Mini Camp
OTA Review: Offensive Linemen In the Trenches
Jun 15 - Hog Wire
Press Release: THN Jumped The Gun
Jun 14 - Hog Wire
Dyson Signed; Other News and Notes
Jun 08 - Hog Wire
Bethea: Never 'Board' With Special Teams
Jun 07 - Interview
OTA Recap: Line Drills
May 26 - Hog Wire
Gouveia Eyeing Return To Burgundy And Gold
May 24 - Hog Wire
Press Release: New Look For THN
May 23 - Hog Wire
NFL – Europe About More Than Just Football
May 21 - Hog Wire
Interview: Adversity Is Hamdan’s Middle Name
May 13 - Hog Wire
Tuipala: The Epitome Of Determination
May 08 - Hog Wire
Diedrick Fired Up In Düsseldorf
Apr 28 - Hog Wire
Redskins Draft Day Party
Apr 27 - Hog Wire
Redskins and Broncos Make Another Deal
Apr 20 - Hog Wire
BA in B and G
Apr 07 - Hog Wire
Riding High on the Hog(ette)
Mar 20 - Hog Wire
So Long Smoot
Mar 09 - Hog Wire
Snyder Gets His Man
Mar 09 - Hog Wire
Buckeye For A Day? No Way
Mar 05 - 2005 Draft
Marshall In The Middle?
Mar 04 - Hog Wire
A Brown Out in Indianapolis
Mar 02 - 2005 Draft
Pro Bowl 2005 Recap – Marcus Washington
Feb 14 - Hog Wire
Team Needs - NFC North
Feb 10 - 2005 Draft
Free Agency Preview - Redskins ERFA
Jan 21 - Hog Wire
Free Agency Preview - Redskins UFA
Jan 17 - Hog Wire
The 5th Quarter - Cowboys
Dec 27 - The 5th Quarter
Springs OK – Out for San Francisco
Dec 17 - Hog Wire
Coach Gibbs Denies Health Rumors
Dec 02 - Hog Wire
The 5th Quarter: Steelers
Dec 01 - The 5th Quarter
Wilson To Get First Career Start
Nov 26 - Hog Wire
The 5th Quarter: Eagles
Nov 22 - The 5th Quarter
Key Player Match-Ups: Eagles
Nov 20 - Game Day
The Future Is Now
Nov 19 - Hog Wire
Ramsey Gets His Shot
Nov 16 - Hog Wire
The 5th Quarter: Lions
Nov 08 - The 5th Quarter
The Call That Broke the Redskins' Back
Nov 02 - Hog Wire
Week 8 Injury Report
Oct 29 - Hog Wire
Pat Tillman: Good Player, Better Man
Oct 28 - Extra
Talking Offense with Dirtbag #1
Oct 24 - Hog Wire
The Rock Displays His 'True Grit'
Oct 21 - Hog Wire
The 5th Quarter: Bears
Oct 18 - The 5th Quarter
Ramsey to Get Chance Sooner Rather Than Later
Sep 21 - Hog Wire
Redskins Name Practice Squad
Sep 07 - Hog Wire
From Starter To Waiver Wire
Aug 18 - Hog Wire
Burgundy and... Brown?
Aug 14 - Hog Wire
Jansen's Injury Tarnishes Gibbs' Return
Aug 10 - Hog Wire
|
|
|
