Author:
SkinsJock
Message:
[quote:7c1c4901f6="cowboykillerzRED"][quote:7c1c4901f6="SkinsJock"]sorry ckR - at this time there is no doubt that Andrew Luck will be the better NFL QB
there's no question that Andrew Luck can get ready to play NOW
RGIII may become a better NFL QB - if I had to choose, I'd take RGIII - in a few years with help, he will become better than Luck
What you see with Luck is what you get - I predict he will be great
I just don't get the feeling that he will be as exciting or as suited to the modern offenses as RGIII
Robert Griffin III is going to become the better QB BUT he is NOT better than Andrew Luck right now
Mike wants him for what he offers not for what he is
HOPEFULLY .... these guys can coach him up and help him become the great QB that he can be[/quote:7c1c4901f6]
In what area?
Completions? Nope
Completion percentage? Nope
Tds? Nope
Fewer ints? Nope
Rush yards? Nope
Rush Tds? Nope
Completions over 20 yards? Nope
Is Luck BETTER then RGIII? NOPE.
Point me to some game film I've missed of him clearly being the more NFL ready (what ever that means) qb.
Rgiii has been and will continue to work on footwork, reading defenses, calling audibles, and taking snaps from under center. To blindly say luck is clearly much better right now.... Is clearly blind of you :)[/quote:7c1c4901f6]
I think you're badly mistaken on 2 points - maybe you're a little biased so it's OK :twisted:
1 RG3 will prove to be the better QB for the Redskins [u:7c1c4901f6]in the future[/u:7c1c4901f6]
AND ... he may even [u:7c1c4901f6]become[/u:7c1c4901f6] a better NFL QB than Andrew Luck
2 Andrew Luck is considered (by people that know more than you or I) to be better prepared to play in the NFL [u:7c1c4901f6]at this time[/u:7c1c4901f6]
I think Mike is correct in his assessment that RG3 is a better fit for what the Redskins want to do than Andrew Luck *
* that in spite of the fact that Andrew Luck is considered (by most that know) to be the better QB
look - both these guys are going to be great - [u:7c1c4901f6]RG3 offers more over the long term[/u:7c1c4901f6] :wink:
I'm looking forward to these coaches and trainers getting RG3 prepared and conditioned to be as good as he can be :D